Indiana 27, Penn State 24
A View from the Past
Back in 1994, that legendary collection of Nittany Lions with Kerry Collins at the helm were cruising toward the mythical national championship when they almost hit a roadblock in the most improbable of venues: Bloomington, Indiana. Undefeated #2 Penn State would face the Hoosiers of yore, Bill Mallory’s 5-4 football team that provided a diversion for a few dozen sports starved fans while waiting for basketball season. The Lions jumped out to a 35-14 lead, which Joe Paterno thought was a good time to clear out the bench. But there was no quit back home in Indiana, where the home team whittled the shocked visitors’ lead down to six points in the fourth quarter. Penn State hung on to win, but came close to blowing their season on the field that day.
Thirty-one years later, the tables were turned. Raucous Beaver Stadium is the site where Curt Cignetti’s undefeated #2 Indiana would take on hapless Penn State, sporting a 3-5 record after five straight losses and going nowhere. This time, it was the Nittany Lions who, with nothing to lose, would scare the Hoosier fan base shitless. In a hotly contested game that would come down to the final play, Indiana took the lead with less than a minute left on the clock. Penn State had enough time left to score a field goal, but couldn’t make the comeback. Final score: Indiana 27, Penn State 24.
Indiana had heretofore been winless in Beaver Stadium and Penn State had dominated the all-time series. But it’s a new dawn, a new day, and a new life. And we ain’t feelin’ good. [Thanks for the fair use, Ira Gershwin].
What Goes Around, Comes Around
So, we’re even. Penn State covered the spread, which closed at 13.5 points, and the over/under was right on the money. And the Nittany Lions played their best game of the year on both sides of the ball. On offense, Ethan Grunkemeyer was finally allowed to throw downfield. Nick Singleton awoke from his slumber to produce 71 yards and two touchdowns. The offensive line appeared to be almost competent. On defense, we finally saw some production out of Dani Dennis-Sutton, who along with his colleagues, kept decent pressure on Fernando Mendoza, recording three sacks.
The Nittany Lions finally woke up in the losing effort, albeit too late in the season to salvage anything meaningful. They will need to beat Moo U., Nebraska, and Rutgers to flirt with bowl eligibility, and even if they manage to do so, the bowl game will be nothing to write home about. Sarcastically, the Sani-Flush Toilet Bowl in Kohler, WI, that winter wonderland in early December, would be the likely venue.
Speaking of “even”, the stats were pretty even. Total yards: Penn State 336, Indiana 326. Indiana had 20 first downs to Penn State’s 17. Grunkemeyer threw for 219 yards; Mendoza, 218. Turnovers’ll killya, though, and although both QBs had one interception, Penn State lost the Franklinesque “turnover battle”. A particularly disastrous Grunkemeyer interception led to a Hoosier score that would eventually provide the winning margin.
While I’m not believing the hype about Fernando Mendoza being the best quarterback in the sport formerly known as college football, I will give credit where due. Mendoza and his talented receivers are a premier bunch. Mendoza’s pinpoint throws in the face of the suddenly resurgent Penn State pass rush were only eclipsed by almost super-human circus catches.
The Nittany Lions had a shot at tying the game in the waning seconds, but clock management bit them in the ass. Instead of spiking the ball to stop the clock, they wasted a time-out, limiting their options as they neared field goal range with the score 27-24. Predictably, time ran out on them.
Now What?
As Penn State football fans cast their collective fate to the wind, what does the future hold? Did the Nittany Lions shoot their proverbial wad in this game? Will the team psyche once again take the elevator to the bargain basement due to post-loss depression and the cumulative mental fatigue of six straight losses?
I hesitate to speculate. I was certainly wrong about them folding their tent after the Ohio State loss. While some of my readers will write this game off as an anomaly or will trivialize the accomplishment because Indiana sucks or has a weak schedule, just about everyone out there was predicting a massacre. It didn’t happen. Indiana came to play, and so did the Nittany Lions.
The current bullshit sentiment that “you ain’t shit less’n you make de playoffs” will dampen acknowledgment of Penn State’s performance. After all, the suckas lost, didn’t they? James Franklin is gone and they still can’t win the big games. Blame it on Franklin.
If fans and Pat Kraft hold this team to such a ridiculously high standard, they’ll always be disappointed and they’ll always be seeking instant fixes. Sorry, people, but life ain’t that easy. If fans could have it their way, every year would be 12-0 and a trip to the playoffs. They’ll never be happy with anything less than perfection, and barring the Second Coming, any coach hired to fix the Lions will be less than perfect. [I got this idea from South Park].
Are the Nittany Lions finally shaking off the shock of James Franklin’s summary dismissal? Is Terry Smith a superior motivator? Or did the notion that laying down on the job would impair NFL prospects finally sink in? I’d say time will tell, but time is running out on this season. Circling the drain with heads held high is the best we fans can expect.
Nothing will salvage this season, but I’ll be happy if they stay competitive, win or lose.
I’ll be back mid-week with a preview of the battle for all the marbles. Yes, folks, that’s right! The Mighty Land Grant Trophy is on the line. It now sports a bag of marbles along with its collection of various and sundry Dollar Store baubles. The Nittany Lions travel to East Lansing to face 3-6 Moo U. Who will come home with the gigantic monstrosity of a booby prize?
Discover more from The Nittany Turkey
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Big Al says
It was a great 2nd half comeback I guess (I left to run some errands after Indiana went up 20-7 in the 3rd quarter and didn’t see it.) But i’m not sure it was that significant for three reasons:
1. Indiana’s best receiver (Sarratt) didn’t play and he’s their only home run threat.
2. It’s really hard to win on the road in the B1G
3, Ohio State is the only genuine top 5 team in the B1G. Indiana will finish the regular season 12-0 and may even win the B1G championship if Day loses to Michigan again and O$U doesn’t make the championship game. But they’re not going to get past the round of eight in the playoffs
IMO The Kitties are still on course to meet their ultimate fate for this season – i.e. becoming the most talented 3-9 team in Penn State football history and the best last place team in B1G football history,
K. John says
I am not sure about that. If we do go 3-9, only the offense would be more talented. Nada on defense. All of the dark year defenses were more talented than the current unit.
The Nittany Turkey says
To their credit, they did manage to put some pressure on Mendoza, recording three sacks. And say what you will about the secondary, two of those throws and catches in the fourth quarter would have confounded NFL cover corners (two-foot rule notwithstanding).
—TNT
Big Al says
State had just one 3-9 team prior to this year – the 2003 team. The 2003 defense had some future NFL players – most notably Tamba Hali, and Alan Zamaitis, but the overall talent level wasn’t better than this year. The 2003 team had better depth at linebacker but this year’s team has a better secondary. The 2003 defense may have had better results, but it was due to better coaching.rather than better talent.
The Nittany Turkey says
Conclusion: Bradley > Knowles?
The Nittany Turkey says
Al,
Sarratt didn’t play, but Cooper and Williams did some serious work. But the deep threat was lacking except when Charlie Becker got lucky with a 53-yard TD reception.
I don’t buy the #2 ranking for Indiana, either. The SEC grinder will devour them in the playoffs.
While I tend to agree that PSU will fold its tent and exit stage left, I am scratching my now bald head about the remaining three games. One part of me says they’ll step up, if only to impress NFL scouts. The other says they’re done for the year, with no potential “statement” games ahead of them.
I’ll still watch them for signs of life.
—TNT