Against the ludicrous backdrop of American Idol’s last year’s scourge, Sanjaya Malakar, coming back to sit in the audience like a bad penny (or a latter-day William Hung), along with a sleazily contrived movie promo that featured Jim Carrey dressed like an elephant popping up at every turn, we watched the first round of eliminations last week, in which the Top 12 were pared down to 11. Erstwhile male stripper David Hernandez was the first finalist to go byebye.
In this Turkey’s opinion, Hernandez’ performance was superior to those of Kristy Lee Cook and Syesha Mercado, but perhaps that opinion reflects the Turkey’s legendary male Chauvinism. In any case, while it is possible that the nefarious information about Hernandez stripping for pay in front of a male audience cost him some votes, his overblown performance last Tuesday surely did not improve his chances with the voting public.
The results show featured a weird performance by last year’s beatboxer, Blake Lewis. Perhaps I just don’t like that kind of novelty crap. However, former Idol runner-up Katharine McPhee also was featured along with David Foster, and McPhee’s legs and butt are better than ever. I approve of the selection of a silver sequined, mid-thigh bottomed sheath for her outfit. It showed off all her star attributes, with which she should have beaten flash-in-the-pan Taylor Hicks that night a couple of years ago. Something must have been in the water when America voted.
This week we once again will be viewing performances from the Lennon-McCartney songbook. In other words, the producers paid dearly for the rights to use it and they’ll damn well milk it for all they can. C’mon folks, ask for yet one more week—Paul needs the money, given that the divorce buy ambien zolpidem settlement totaled about $44 million.
I am hoping for a strong performance tonight by Ramiele Malubay (who says she’s from Miramar, Florida, but the Orlando Sentinel has claimed her as our own). Ramiele has a big voice for a little girl, but she has slipped in recent weeks from looking at one point as if she could win it all. Self-confidence might be an issue with her. From the guys, I was really energized by Chikezie’s imaginatively produced and delivered number last week, and hope for more of the same this week. I am further hoping for a nice, revealing, form fitting outfit for this Turkey’s favorite blond equestrian eye candy, Kristy Lee Cook, as this could well be her last week. (You know what “they” say about too many cooks…) If Kristy’s number isn’t up, Syesha better hope that her very pretty and electric smile saves her fine ass for another week.
I would look for some hard rocking stylings by David Cook and Amanda Overmyer. They’re the edgy ones in this year’s final group.
Oh, and David Archuleta will certainly survive at least several more weeks, inasmuch as the pre-pubescent and early teen girls comprising a large segment of the voting audience are solidly in his camp. His singing had been solid up to the past couple of weeks, but confidence issues suddenly might be getting in the way.
It remains to be seen whether Paula will be lucid or out of it; whether Simon Cowell will spend the evening Scowelling; and whether Seacrest will continue to throw instigating barbs at Simon. If you didn’t read last week’s column, I likened the judges to children: Fat Albert, Rebecca of Sunnybrook Farm, and Eddie Haskell.
Discover more from The Nittany Turkey
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.


Hey Turkey! Is this where we’re meeting?
This must be da place.
The costume department is working overtime.
Good evening, Turkey–it’s good to be back!
I’m a HUGE Beatles fan so don’t mess with me 🙂
I have mixed feelings about AI doing The Beatles. It’s sort of demeaning.
To the band.
I tend to agree with you on that. And Amanda isn’t singing the right song for her.
I think she’s okay, however I don’t think she and the band are on the same page. In fact, I think the band sucks.
She needs to do minor key stuff.
She’s doing the song the way she thinks she should do it to be “cool.”
I wonder who does the arrangements for the band.
It was contrived.
And Paula, when the sun shines, it doesn’t rain.
I agree with Simon–and this is the first time I’ve seen Amanda!
Amanda WILL become boring because of her sameness week to week. Point made, Simon.
Ah, but Turkey, in Florida, the sun and the rain often coincide.
She was in a Janis groove for quite a while.
Yeah–Amanda’s style sounds like what you’d hear in a bar.
Amanda is a nurse who delivers portable medical devices to old codgers like me.
But that’s not always a bad thing. I’ve seen some great bar bands.
What kind of “portable devices?”
Poopy kind???
Coming up: perhaps our last look at Kristy Lee Cook. I didn’t like the outfit, though.
No, like oxygen thingies and the like.
Jesus, Shaq…is THIS what it’s come to?
Is Kristie your hottie?
I missed the Shaq thing–what happened?
He was in a vitamin water commercial…as a jockey.
She’s going to sink this song.
It’s already better than last week.
This song has drama written into it–it does not need the added histrionics.
Oops, flat note.
Check those legs.
I really don’t like this interp. of the song.
It’s about 300% better than last week.
Yeah, yeah, the legs.
Ah, the way she looks tonight.
Hypnosis. Yeah, that’s it.
Wow–is it true, those things Simon is saying?
Hang on to your socks, Ben!!!
And now the 17 year-old who looks 13: our Bar Mitzvah boy, David Archuleta.
He’s got the 11 year-old vote wrapped up.
He’s a good singer, but he needs a five o’clock shadow and a couple scars to be believable.
It’s a bit smooth but I like what he’s doing for the most part. This is a hard song to sing, even for McCartney. I think he’s doing a good job, and with feeling.
Yeah, David will get lots of votes for that (and the other thing).
Wonderful, purity, rise above adversity, reveals character.
I like what Paula said.
The kid did good.
He looks stunned? No, he looks 12.
Yeah, he really looks young!
The Aussie from Atlanta is next. He’s good looking and entertaining, but not spectacular. Neither spectacularly good nor spectacularly bad.
So, Turkey–I think it’s fitting we have another Beatles night since the Mac/Mills divorce has finally been “officially” setttled.
Poor Paul. He’ll never be rid of her.
Yeah, like was that &*$@&(@ worth $44 million?
Heather’s a nut job.
Why oh why didn’t he sign a pre-nup???
This is a bunch of bullshit. I cannot believe the powers that be are allowing one of these kids to do A Day in the Life.’
I am NOT amused.
This song meant something…now it’s been reduced to this.
You tell ’em. A strongly worded letter to Nigel Lithgoe will do.
He sort of reminds me of Jim Morrison.
A little pitchy in places. (Not the song but the whining from 700 Euclid.)
Who is Nigel Lithgoe?
This guy is a teen hearthrob.
OK…let him have it. Go Patti.
SSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSS.
Yeah, simon wouldn’t understand.
Right on, Simon! It is a complicated song and isn’t meant for this type of performance.
Simon, however, speakum truth.
Wow—control is slipping away.
Please don’t vote until the end of the show.
Brooke White…the nanny turned singer. She’s a Carly Simon type.
Are you there, Turkey?
And I’m James Taylor.
Why? Did I go somewhere?
There’s also a singer by the name of “Carly” tonight, right?
I thought much of James Taylor’s output was insipid. And Carly Simon was striking and had a great voice but turned out to be a self-centered pain in the ass which eventually equalled BORING.
Yeah, Carly is the Irish babe from San Diego with the tattoos.
Yikes! Look at the 80s hair-do!
You’re so vain
you problee think this song is aboutya
INCOMINGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGG
It’s a good song and hard to ruin.
If it wasn’t such a good song her performance would get a thorough “thumbs down.”
Some kinds 1968 go-go outfit.
Not good.
She has nice knees.
Paula sure does sparkle tonight!
She must have drunk some battery acid.
She needs to shut up!
It’s okay.
We get it.
Brooke baby…do what you do.
Who is up next, Ben-o-rem-o?
Official Turkey book on David Cook: Scruffy. Needs new haircut. But can rock. Been known to pick wrong song, but also known to take a song and make it his own. Sometimes performs with guitar. Attitude sometimes sucks, but hell, he’s a musician. What do you expect?
David is definitely not a flatliner. He’s either good or bad, but never ordinary.
The Beatles didn’t pose when they performed this–they sang, straight and true–it was authentic.
This guy is a poser.
What a fake.
LOL
Take the one way ticket to the backstage area–and stay there.
😀
I thought that was pretty damn good.
Call McCartney and get his opinion.
Thank you, Simon.
He does look smug.
He looked pissed. Who does this kid think he is? He’s got to learn a bit, doesn’t he, luv?
Oh, wait…he’s in the poorhouse.
I like his edge. A little cockiness is refreshing from these jokers.
Hey, Carly is coming up!
She has a tattoo of a face on her arm. But she can sing.
Edge is good, but this guy seems like an a—h—.
She’s a solid performer. It’s all in the song selection, but she’s usually chosen wisely.
All right! Get Down, Carly!
Tell MathDude that I’m overdue for lunch but the next couple of weeks are nigh on to impossible.
Have you seen the pictures of Pauly out today? He’s not looking good. Poor chap has been through the ringer.
You are a busy Turkey!
I’ll tell him.
Just don’t get over-cooked 🙂
Hell, he looked bad two years ago.
I think Paula is pretty funny tonight.
Randy’s wrist beads are very pretty.
I would say it’s just a-ight. But then, I’m not Randy.
The song is abridged so that doesn’t help.
She’s got a good voice but there’s nothing special in her rendition.
She’s doing better now that she amped it up.
She has good control and she’s technically sound, unlike some of them.
These kids have learned from Whitney Houston and her ilk that it’s about The Voice and not The Song.
Wrong.
Simon is going to disagree.
She should flip a bird at Simon.
Way to go, Simon!
Okay, I get it, Carly…but that’s no excuse.
Predictable.
Wonder who’s going to do the crap songs like Ooo-bla-dee and Yellow Submarine?
I’m with Simon on this one.
There are many more songs in that catelog–they never need dip into O-bla and Yellow Sub.
OK. Wonder who’s gonna do Yesterchelle.
On another topic:
My dogs have MAJOR gas issues.
Okay, guys–time to clear out of the room!
Now, Jason Castro. He has some kinda hair.
You been feeding them soybean protein?
No soy but pumpkin.
Who is Jason?
How about Baby You’re a Rich Man, Too!
(suggested by Heather Mills.)
Yikes.
A-ha!
Tres bien ensemble
Sucks.
Vous et miserable, Jason.
Too much of a poser.
This is an ongoing problem.
But Jason is shy and the little girlies like him.
Somewhere, Beatles are either laughing…
or crying.
Uh…DUH!!!
We still have two potentially good ones in Chikezie and Ramiele. And I agree with Simon that too many Beatles songs is too many.
It is damn weird!
Simon is right on it. The Beatles were about more than charm–
they were musicians and artists.
Oh, jeez. Really laying it on. 🙂
Who are these two–
Chikezie and Ramiele
???
Now we have the completion of the Yesterchelle dyad.
Is this is Yiddish thing–Yesterchelle?
FOrgot all about Syesha Mercado. She’s pretty forgettable, except for her pretty smile. We don’t really need another Whitney who drank from Mariah’s glass by mistake.
Chikezie is a Nigerian-American who is a lot of fun. He can sing, too. Ramiele is a Filipino-American who is 4’11” but with a huge voice you won’t believe can come from lungs that small.
I don’t know what I think about Syesha doing Yesterday. I don’t think she can make it believable.
Speaking of Mariah–did you hear that she recently used the word “dichotomy” in a sentence?
Holy shit!!
NICE OUTFIT, Syesha!!! 😀
Someone needs to do Norwegian Wood.
Or how about Revolution No. 9.
Someone should piss on the judges by doing “Good Vibrations.”
It would help if she would sing it in tune without the runs and note shifts.
Man does her syncopation suck! 🙁
Now we get into the screaming shit.
I don’t hate this. She’s inflecting it with some true emotion.
Not bad.
Oops, I’m posting too fast. I like her looks. Don’t like her singing.
Paula is irrelevant. She’ll never say anything bad.
Paula is looking younger.
Simon and I are on the same page.
She probably got a body lift or something.
That would be page 86?
Beyoncaroo
Beyoncaroo
???
Turkey, you have got to rent the movie, Once.
It’s great.
I don’t like musicals.
It’s nothing like that–at all. I don’t like musicals either. Trust me on this one.
You sure it’s not like Hairspray?
Not even in the most remote way.
Not even like Hair Gel.
Just kidding.
This guy should be entertaining.
This is a good tune. Interesting choice.
He starts slow but picks up, if he’s working his typical pattern.
Yeah…do it, Keezie!
Ben love Chikezie.
Boring at the start.
He picked up the energy which was true to the song…but
a bit gimmicky.
When he was singing, my dog Merlin got really freaked out and ran out of the room!!!!
Thank you, Simon.
The voice of reason.
You and Simon been drinking from the same mead cup.
Ha, Simon agrees with me!
Okay, Ben-O–who is the last performer?
Ramiele batting cleanup. She better make it worth my waiting for her. She’s blown me away a few times, but the past few weeks she’s been off her game. Ill at ease, I think. She might not be emotionally suited to the rigors of the cruel music business.
Who is? That’s why so many of them do drugs!
I sing in the shower and I don’t need no steenking drugs.
By the way, you have got to rent The Wire.
Don’t need the late Maharishi Mahesh Yogi, either.
I’ll put it on my list.
Okay…here we go.
Good song!
Would help if she hit the notes.
This is fun. She’s not doing a great job but she’s hanging in.
It is not a good song for her, though. She didn’t do anything with it until the end.
She’s a bit too timid with it.
She is a cutie.
When is the Dusty Springfield show?
That should be cool.
Simon says.
But she’s safe, because Kristy gave the least memorable performance of the night and even her tall blondeness won’t save her.
Someone did Dusty in the early rounds and nailed the song.
I guess the rugrat had the best performance of the night.
I think it was Carly Smithson who did the Dusty song.
My votes:
David (not Cook)…Syesha…Ramiele.
And Brooke.
Maybe not the best vocalists but they had heart.
You gotta have heart.
I’m signing off. Back to work.
G’night Turkey! See you tomorrow!
Good night and good luck.